---
title: "Using and understanding a Chromatograms object"
output:
    BiocStyle::html_document:
        toc_float: true
vignette: >
    %\VignetteIndexEntry{Using and understanding a Chromatograms object}
    %\VignetteEngine{knitr::rmarkdown}
    %\VignetteEncoding{UTF-8}
    %\VignettePackage{Chromatograms}
    %\VignetteDepends{Chromatograms,BiocStyle,mzR,msdata,Spectra,MsBackendMetaboLights}
---

```{r style, echo = FALSE, results = 'asis', message=FALSE}
BiocStyle::markdown()
```

**Package**: `r BiocStyle::pkg_ver('Chromatograms')` <br />
**Compiled**: `r date()`

```{r, echo = FALSE, message = FALSE}
library(Chromatograms)
library(BiocStyle)
register(SerialParam())
```


# Introduction

The *Chromatograms* package provides a scalable and flexible infrastructure to
represent, retrieve, and handle chromatographic data. The `Chromatograms`
object offers a standardized interface to access and manipulate chromatographic
data while supporting various ways to store and retrieve this data through the
concept of exchangeable *backends*. This vignette provides general examples
and descriptions for the *Chromatograms* package.

Contributions to this vignette (content or correction of typos) or requests for
additional details and information are highly welcome, ideally *via* pull
requests or *issues* on the package's
[github repository](https://github.com/RforMassSpectrometry/Chromatograms).

This vignette describe the structure of a Chromatograms object and the methods
that need to be implemented. In order to see the structure of the object, the
`@` accessor is used to access the different slots. This is possible because
the `Chromatograms` class is defined as an S4 class. However users should not
use the `@` accessor to access the data stored in a `Chromatograms` object, but
instead use the methods defined by the `Chromatograms` class.


# Installation

The package can be installed with the *BiocManager* package. To install
*BiocManager*, use `install.packages("BiocManager")`, and after that, use
`BiocManager::install("Chromatograms")` to install
*Chromatograms*.


# The Chromatograms object

The `Chromatograms` object is a container for chromatographic data, which
includes peaks data (*retention time* and related intensity values, also\
referred to as *peaks data variables* in the context of `Chromatograms`) and
metadata of individual chromatograms (so-called *chromatogram variables*).
While a core set of chromatogram variables (the `coreChromatogramsVariables()`)
and peaks data variables (the `corePeaksVariables()`) are guaranteed to be
provided by a `Chromatograms`, it is possible to add arbitrary variables to
a `Chromatograms` object.

The `Chromatograms` object is designed to contain chromatographic data for a
(large) set of chromatograms. The data is organized *linearly* and can be
thought of as a list of chromatograms, where each element in the
`Chromatograms` is one chromatogram.

## Available backends

Backends allow to use different *backends* to store chromatographic data while
providing *via* the `Chromatograms` class a unified interface to use that data.
The `Chromatograms` package defines a
set of example backends but any object extending the base `ChromBackend` class
could be used instead. The default backends are:

- `ChromBackendMemory`: the *default* backend to store data in memory. Due to
  its design the `ChromBackendMemory` provides fast access to the peaks data
  and metadata. Since all data is kept in memory, this backend has a
  relatively large memory footprint (depending on the data) and is thus not
  suggested for very large experiments.

- `ChromBackendMzR`: this backend keeps only the chromatographic metadata
  variables in memory and relies on the `r Biocpkg("mzR")` package to read
  chromatographic peaks (retention time and intensity values) from the
  original mzML files on-demand.

- `ChromBackendSpectra`: this backend generates chromatographic data from a
  `Spectra` object. It can be used to create Total Ion Chromatograms (TIC),
  Base Peak Chromatograms (BPC), or Extracted Ion Chromatograms (EICs). It
  supports both in-memory and file-backed `Spectra` objects. The backend uses
  **factorization** to group spectra into chromatograms based on variables like
  MS level and data origin (see details below).

All backends provide a consistent interface through the `Chromatograms` object,
regardless of where or how the data is stored. The `ChromBackendSpectra` has
a special feature: it uses an internal sort index (`spectraSortIndex`) to
maintain retention time order without physically reordering the underlying
`Spectra` object. This is particularly important for disk-backed `Spectra`
objects, as it avoids loading all data into memory. The sort index is
automatically maintained during subsetting and factorization operations.

## Chromatographic peaks data

The *peaks data variables* information in the `Chromatograms` object can be
accessed using the `peaksData()` function.
`peaksData` can be accessed, replaced, and also filtered/subsetted.

The *core peaks data variables* all have their own accessors and are as
follows:

- `rtime`: A `numeric` vector containing retention time values.
- `intensity`: A `numeric` vector containing intensity values.

## Chromatograms metadata

The metadata of individual chromatograms (so called
*chromatograms variables*), can be accessed using the `chromData()` function.
The `chromData` can be accessed, replaced, and filtered.

The *core chromatogram variables* all have their own accessor methods, and it
is guaranteed that a value is returned by them (or `NA` if the information is
not available).

The core variables and their data types are (alphabetically ordered):

- `chromIndex`: an `integer` with the index of the chromatogram in the
  original source file (e.g., *mzML* file).
- `collisionEnergy`: for SRM data, `numeric` with the collision energy of the
  precursor.
- `dataOrigin`: optional `character` with the origin of a chromatogram.
- `storageLocation`: `character` defining where the data is (currently) stored.
- `msLevel`: `integer` defining the MS level of the data.
- `mz`: optional `numeric` with the (target) m/z value for the chromatographic
  data.
- `mzMin`: optional `numeric` with the lower m/z value of the m/z range in case
   the data (e.g., an extracted ion chromatogram EIC) was extracted from a
  `Chromtagorams` object.
- `mzMax`: optional `numeric` with the upper m/z value of the m/z range.
- `precursorMz`: for SRM data, `numeric` with the target m/z of the precursor
  (parent).
- `precursorMzMin`: for SRM data, optional `numeric` with the lower m/z of the
  precursor's isolation window.
- `precursorMzMax`: for SRM data, optional `numeric` with the upper m/z of the
  precursor's isolation window.
- `productMz`: for SRM data, `numeric` with the target m/z of the product ion.
- `productMzMin`: for SRM data, optional `numeric` with the lower m/z of the
  product's isolation window.
- `productMzMax`: for SRM data, optional `numeric` with the upper m/z of the
  product's isolation window.

For details on the individual variables and their getter/setter functions, see
the help for `Chromatograms` (`?Chromatograms`). Also, note that these
variables are suggested but not required to characterize a chromatogram.

## Creating `Chromatograms` objects

The simplest way to create a `Chromatograms` object is by defining a backend
ofchoice, which mainly depends on what type of data you have, and passing that
to the `Chromatograms` constructor function. Below we create such an object for
a set of 2 chromatograms, providing their metadata through a data.frame with
the MS level, m/z, and chromatogram index columns, and peaks data. The metadata
includes the MS level, m/z, and chromatogram index, while the peaks data
includes the retention time and intensity in a list of data.frames.

```{r}
# A data.frame with chromatogram variables.
cdata <- data.frame(
    msLevel = c(1L, 1L),
    mz = c(112.2, 123.3),
    chromIndex = c(1L, 2L)
)

# Retention time and intensity values for each chromatogram.
pdata <- list(
    data.frame(
        rtime = c(11, 12.4, 12.8, 13.2, 14.6, 15.1, 16.5),
        intensity = c(50.5, 123.3, 153.6, 2354.3, 243.4, 123.4, 83.2)
    ),
    data.frame(
        rtime = c(45.1, 46.2, 53, 54.2, 55.3, 56.4, 57.5),
        intensity = c(100, 180.1, 300.45, 1400, 1200.3, 300.2, 150.1)
    )
)

# Create and initialize the backend
be <- backendInitialize(ChromBackendMemory(),
    chromData = cdata, peaksData = pdata
)

# Create Chromatograms object
chr <- Chromatograms(be)
chr
```

Alternatively, it is possible to import chromatograhic data from mass
spectrometry raw files in mzML/mzXML or CDF format. Below, we create a
`Chromatograms` object from an mzML file and define to use a `ChromBackendMzR`
backend to *store* the data (note that this requires the `r Biocpkg("mzR")`
package to be installed). This backend, specifically designed for raw LC-MS
data, keeps only a subset of chromatogram variables in memory while reading the
retention time and intensity values from the original data files only on
demand. See section [Backends](#backends) for more details on backends and
their properties.

```{r}
MRM_file <- system.file("proteomics", "MRM-standmix-5.mzML.gz",
    package = "msdata"
)

be <- backendInitialize(ChromBackendMzR(),
    files = MRM_file,
    BPPARAM = SerialParam()
)

chr_mzr <- Chromatograms(be)
```

The `Chromatograms` object `chr_mzr` now contains the chromatograms from the
mzML file `MRM_file`. The chromatograms can be accessed and manipulated using
the `Chromatograms` object's methods and functions.

It is also possible to create a `Chromatograms` object directly from a
`Spectra` object. This is particularly useful when you want to generate total
ion chromatograms (TIC), base peak chromatograms (BPC), or extracted ion
chromatograms (EIC) from spectral data. A worked example is provided in the
[plotting](#plotting-chromatograms-from-a-spectra-object) section below.

Basic information about the `Chromatograms` object can be accessed using
functions such as `length()`, which tell us how many chromatograms are
contained in the object:

```{r}
length(chr)
length(chr_mzr)
```


# Access data from a Chromatograms object

The `Chromatograms` object provides a set of methods to access and manipulate
the chromatographic data. The following sections describe how to do such
thingson the peaks data and related metadata.

## peaksData

The main function to access the full or a part of the peaks data is
`peaksData()` (imaginative right), This function returns a list of data.frames,
where each data.frame contains the retention time and intensity values for one
chromatogram. It is used such as below:

```{r}
peaksData(chr)
```

Specific peaks variables can be accessed by either precising the `"columns"`
parameter in `peaksData()` or using `$`.

```{r}
peaksData(chr, columns = c("rtime"), drop = TRUE)

chr$rtime
```

The methods above also allows to replace the peaks data. It can either be the
full peaks data:

```{r}
peaksData(chr) <- list(
    data.frame(
        rtime = c(1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7),
        intensity = c(1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)
    ),
    data.frame(
        rtime = c(1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7),
        intensity = c(1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)
    )
)
```

Or for specific variables:

```{r}
chr$rtime <- list(
    c(8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14),
    c(8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14)
)
```

The peak data can be therefore accessed, replaced but also filtered/subsetted.
The filtering can be done using the `filterPeaksData()` function. This function
filters numerical peaks data variables based on the specified numerical ranges
parameter. This function does not reduce the number of chromatograms in the
object, but it removes the specified peaks data (e.g., "rtime" and "intensity"
pairs) from the peaksData.

```{r}
chr_filt <- filterPeaksData(chr, variables = "rtime", ranges = c(12, 15))

length(chr_filt)

length(rtime(chr_filt))
```

As you can see the number of chromatograms in the `Chromatograms` object is not
reduced, but the peaks data is filtered/reduced.

## chromData

The main function to access the full chromatographic metadata is
`chromData()`.This function returns the metadata of the chromatograms stored
in the `Chromatograms` object. It can be used as follows:

```{r}
chromData(chr)
```

Specific chromatogram variables can be accessed by either precising the
`"columns"` parameter in `chromData()` or using `$`.

```{r}
chromData(chr, columns = c("msLevel"))

chr$chromIndex
```

The metadata can be replaced using the same methods as for the peaks data.

```{r}
chr$msLevel <- c(2L, 2L)

chromData(chr)
```

extra columns can also be added by the user using the `$` operator.

```{r}
chr$extra <- c("extra1", "extra2")
chromData(chr)
```

As for the peaks data, the filtering can be done using the `filterChromData()`
function. This function filters the chromatogram variables based on the
specified ranges parameter.
However, contrarily to the peaks data, the filtering *does* reduces the number
of chromatograms in the object.

```{r}
chr_filt <- filterChromData(chr,
    variables = "chromIndex", ranges = c(1, 2),
    keep = TRUE
)

length(chr_filt)
length(chr)
```

The number of chromatograms in the `Chromatograms` object is reduced.

Note that for `ChromBackendSpectra`, when you subset the `Chromatograms` object,
the underlying `Spectra` object and its sort index are also properly subset and
updated. This ensures that peak data extraction remains efficient even after
subsetting operations.

### Re-factorizing after metadata changes

If you modify the chromatogram metadata (particularly the factorization columns
like `msLevel` or `dataOrigin`), you may need to re-factorize the data to update
the groupings. This can be done using the `factorize()` function:

```{r, eval=FALSE}
## Modify metadata
chr_s$msLevel <- rep(2L, length(chr_s))

## Re-factorize to update the groupings
chr_s <- factorize(chr_s)

chromData(chr_s)
```

This recalculates which spectra belong to which chromatograms based on the
updated metadata.


# Lazy Processing and Parallelization

The `Chromatograms` object is designed to be scalable and flexible. It is
therefore possible to perform processing in a lazy manner, i.e., only when
the data is needed, and in a parallelized way.

## Processing queue

Some functions, such as those that require reading large amounts of data
from source files, are deferred and executed only when the data is needed.
For example, when `filterPeaksData()` is applied, it initially returns the
same `Chromatograms` object as the input, but the filtering step is stored
in the processing queue of the object. Later, when `peaksData` is accessed,
all stacked operations are performed, and the updated data is returned.

This approach is particularly important for backends that do not store
data in memory, such as `ChromBackendMzR`. It ensures that data is read
from the source file only when required, reducing memory usage. However,
loading and processing data in smaller chunks can further minimize memory
demands, allowing efficient handling of large datasets.

It is possible to add also custom functions to the processing queue of the
object. Such a function can be applicable to both the peaks data and the
chromatogram metadata. Below we demonstrate how to add a custom function to
the processing queue of a `Chromatograms` object. Below we define a function
that divides the intensities of each peak by a value which can
be passed with argument `y`.

```{r define-function}
## Define a function that takes the backend as an input, divides the intensity
## by parameter y and returns it. Note that ... is required in
## the function's definition.
divide_intensities <- function(x, y, ...) {
    intensity(x) <- lapply(intensity(x), `/`, y)
    x
}

## Add the function to the procesing queue
chr_2 <- addProcessing(chr, divide_intensities, y = 2)
chr_2
```

Object `chr_2` has now 2 processing steps in its lazy evaluation queue. Calling
`intensity()` on this object will now return intensities that are half of the
intensities of the original objects `chr`.

```{r custom-processing}
intensity(chr_2)
intensity(chr)
```

Finally, for `Chromatograms` that use a *writeable* backend, such as the
`ChromBackendMemory` it is possible to apply the processing queue to the peak
data and write that back to the data storage with the `applyProcessing()`
function. Below we use this to make all data manipulations on peak data of
the `sps_rep` object persistent.

```{r applyProcessing}
length(chr_2@processingQueue)
chr_2 <- applyProcessing(chr_2)

length(chr_2@processingQueue)
chr_2
```

Before `applyProcessing()` the lazy evaluation queue contained 2 processing
steps, which were then applied to the peak data and *written* to the data
storage. Note that calling `reset()` **after** `applyProcessing()` can no
longer *restore* the data.


## Parallelization

The functions are designed to run in multiple chunks (i.e., pieces) of the
object simultaneously, enabling parallelization. This is achieved using
the `BiocParallel` package. For `ChromBackendMzR`, data is automatically
split and processed by files.

For other backends, chunk-wise processing can be enabled by setting the
`processingChunkSize` of a `Chromatograms` object, which defines the
number of chromatograms for which peak data should be loaded and processed
in each iteration. The `processingChunkFactor()` function can be used to
evaluate how the data will be split. Below, we use this function to assess
how chunk-wise processing would be performed with two `Chromatograms`
objects:

```{r}
processingChunkFactor(chr)
```

For the `Chromatograms` with the in-memory backend an empty `factor()` is
returned, thus, no chunk-wise processing will be performed. We next evaluate
whether the `Chromatograms` with the `ChromBackendMzR` on-disk backend would
use chunk-wise processing.

```{r}
processingChunkFactor(chr_mzr) |>
  head()
```

Here the factor would on  yl be of length 1, meaning that all chromatograms
will be processed in one go. however the length would be higher if more than
one file is used. As this data is quite big (`r length(chr_mzr)`
chromatograms), we can set the `processingChunkSize` to 10 to process the data
in chunks of 10 chromatograms.

```{r}
processingChunkSize(chr_mzr) <- 10

processingChunkFactor(chr_mzr) |> table()
```

The `Chromatograms` with the `ChromBackendMzR` backend would now split the data
in about equally sized arbitrary chunks and no longer by original data file.
`processingChunkSize` thus overrides any splitting suggested by the backend.

While chunk-wise processing reduces the memory demand of operations, the
splitting and merging of the data and results can negatively impact
performance. Thus, small data sets or `Chromatograms` with in-memory backends
willgenerally not benefit from this type of processing. For computationally
intense operation on the other hand, chunk-wise processing has the advantage,
that chunks can (and will) be processed in parallel (depending on the parallel
processing setup).


# Changing backend type

In the previous sections we learned already that a `Chromatograms` object can
use different backends for the actual data handling. It is also possible to
change the backend of a `Chromatograms` to a different one with the
`setBackend()` function. As of now it is only possible to change
the `ChrombackendMzR` to an in-memory backend such as `ChromBackendMemory`.

```{r}
print(object.size(chr_mzr), units = "Mb")
chr_mzr <- setBackend(chr_mzr, ChromBackendMemory(), BPPARAM = SerialParam())

chr_mzr

chr_mzr@backend@peaksData[[1]] |> head() # data is now in memory
```

With the call the full peak data was imported from the original mzML files into
the object. This has obviously an impact on the object's size, which is now
much larger than before.

```{r}
print(object.size(chr_mzr), units = "Mb")
```

## Choosing the right backend

Different backends are suited for different use cases:

- **`ChromBackendMemory`**: Best for small to medium datasets where fast access
  is needed. All data is kept in memory, providing the fastest access but higher
  memory consumption.

- **`ChromBackendMzR`**: Ideal for large datasets stored in mzML/mzXML/CDF files.
  Only metadata is kept in memory, while peak data is read on-demand, significantly
  reducing memory footprint at the cost of slower data access.

- **`ChromBackendSpectra`**: Perfect for generating chromatograms from spectral
  data, especially when creating TICs, BPCs, or EICs from existing `Spectra`
  objects. The backend intelligently handles both in-memory and disk-backed
  `Spectra` objects through its internal sorting mechanism, avoiding unnecessary
  memory consumption while maintaining good performance.


# Plotting chromatograms from a `Spectra` object

For this purpose let's create a lightweight in-memory `Spectra` object and
derive a `Chromatograms` from it. This avoids any external downloads while
still illustrating the `ChromBackendSpectra` workflow.

```{r, message=FALSE}
library(Spectra)
library(IRanges)
sp <- Spectra(
  DataFrame(
    rtime = c(100, 110, 120, 130, 140),
    msLevel = c(1L, 1L, 1L, 1L, 1L),
    dataOrigin = rep("example", 5L),
    mz = NumericList(
      c(100, 101), c(100, 101), c(100, 101), c(100, 101), c(100, 101),
      compress = FALSE
    ),
    intensity = NumericList(
      c(10, 20), c(15, 25), c(30, 5), c(12, 18), c(40, 2),
      compress = FALSE
    )
  ),
  source = MsBackendDataFrame()
)

chr_s <- Chromatograms(sp)
```

We now have a `Chromatograms` object `chr_s` with a `ChromBackendSpectra`
backend. one chromatogram was generated per file.

```{r}
chr_s
```

The `ChromBackendSpectra` backend provides flexibility in how chromatograms are
generated from spectral data through a process called **factorization**.

## Understanding Factorization

Factorization is the process of grouping individual spectra into chromatograms
based on one or more variables. Think of it as creating separate "bins" where
each bin becomes one chromatogram.

By default, the `factorize.by` parameter is set to `c("msLevel", "dataOrigin")`,
which means:

- All MS1 spectra from file "A" → Chromatogram 1
- All MS2 spectra from file "A" → Chromatogram 2
- All MS1 spectra from file "B" → Chromatogram 3
- All MS2 spectra from file "B" → Chromatogram 4

Each unique combination of the factorization variables creates a separate
chromatogram. This allows you to organize your spectral data into meaningful
chromatographic traces that can be visualized and analyzed together.

You can customize the factorization behavior by changing the `factorize.by`
parameter. For example, using only `factorize.by = "dataOrigin"` would create
one chromatogram per file (combining all MS levels), while adding more variables
would create more granular groupings.

Additionally, you can provide custom chromatogram metadata to define specific
m/z and retention time ranges:

```{r}
## Create custom metadata for EIC extraction
custom_cd <- data.frame(
    msLevel = c(1L, 1L),
    dataOrigin = rep(dataOrigin(sp)[1], 2),
    mzMin = c(100, 200),
    mzMax = c(100.5, 200.5)
)

chr_custom <- Chromatograms(sp, chromData = custom_cd)
chr_custom
```

This approach allows you to pre-define the chromatographic regions you want to
extract, which is useful for targeted analysis workflows.

Now, let's say we want to plot specific area of the chromatograms.

```{r}
chromData(chr_s)$rtmin <- 125
chromData(chr_s)$rtmax <- 180
chromData(chr_s)$mzmin <- 100
chromData(chr_s)$mzmax <- 100.5
```

The `Chromatograms` object provides a set of functions to plot the
chromatograms and their peaks data. The `plotChromatograms()` function can be
used to plot each single chromatograms into its own plot.

```{r}
library(RColorBrewer)
col3 <- brewer.pal(3, "Dark2")

plotChromatograms(chr_s, col = col3)
```

On the overhand if the users wants to easily compare the chromatograms, the
`plotChromatogramsOverlay()` function can be used to overlay all chromatograms
into one plot.

```{r}
plotChromatogramsOverlay(chr_s, col = col3)
```

# Extracting chromatographic regions of interest

The `chromExtract()` function allows you to extract specific regions of interest
from a `Chromatograms` object based on a peak table. This is particularly useful
when you want to focus on specific retention time windows or m/z ranges that
correspond to detected peaks or features of interest.

## Basic extraction by retention time

For backends like `ChromBackendMemory` and `ChromBackendMzR`, you can extract
regions based on retention time ranges:

```{r}
## Define peaks of interest with retention time windows
peak_table <- data.frame(
    rtMin = c(8, 11),
    rtMax = c(10, 13),
    msLevel = c(2L, 2L),
    chromIndex = c(1L, 2L)
)

## Extract those regions
chr_extracted <- chromExtract(chr, peak_table,
                              by = c("msLevel", "chromIndex"))

chr_extracted
```

The resulting `Chromatograms` object contains only the data within the specified
retention time windows. Note that extra columns in `peak_table` are added to
the chromatogram metadata:

```{r}
chromData(chr_extracted)
```

## Extraction with m/z filtering (ChromBackendSpectra only)

When using `ChromBackendSpectra`, you can also filter by m/z ranges, which is
useful for extracting ion chromatograms (EICs) for specific mass windows:

```{r}
## Define peak table with both retention time and m/z windows
peak_table_mz <- data.frame(
    rtMin = c(125, 125),
    rtMax = c(180, 180),
    mzMin = c(100, 140),
    mzMax = c(100.5, 140.5),
    msLevel = c(1L, 1L),
    dataOrigin = rep(dataOrigin(chr_s)[1], 2),
    featureID = c("feature_1", "feature_2")
)

## Extract EICs for these features
chr_eics <- chromExtract(chr_s, peak_table_mz,
                        by = c("msLevel", "dataOrigin"))

chr_eics
```

Notice that the custom column `featureID` from the peak table is now part of
the chromatogram metadata:

```{r}
chromData(chr_eics)
```

This is particularly useful for linking extracted chromatograms back to
feature tables or peak detection results.

# Imputing missing values in chromatograms

Real chromatographic data often has gaps or missing intensity values at certain
retention times, which can occur due to instrumental limitations, data processing
artifacts, or sparse sampling. The `imputePeaksData()` function provides several
methods to interpolate these missing values, which can improve downstream
analysis and visualization.

## Available imputation methods

The package provides four imputation methods:

- **"linear"**: Linear interpolation between known values. Fast and simple, good
  for data with regular gaps.
- **"spline"**: Cubic spline interpolation. Provides smooth curves but may
  introduce artifacts.
- **"gaussian"**: Gaussian kernel smoothing. Uses a Gaussian kernel to estimate
  values based on neighboring points.
- **"loess"**: Locally weighted scatter plot smoothing. Provides robust smoothing
  with local polynomial regression.

## Example: Imputing an extracted ion chromatogram (EIC)

Let's extract a narrow m/z range EIC and then apply different imputation methods:

```{r}
## Create a specific EIC
eic_table <- data.frame(
    rtMin = 125,
    rtMax = 180,
    mzMin = 100.01,
    mzMax = 100.02,
    msLevel = 1L,
    dataOrigin = dataOrigin(chr_s)[1]
)

chr_eic <- chromExtract(chr_s, eic_table, by = c("msLevel", "dataOrigin"))
chr_eic
```

Now let's examine the raw data and apply different imputation methods:

```{r, fig.height=10, fig.width=8}
## Create copies for comparison
chr_linear <- imputePeaksData(chr_eic, method = "linear")
chr_spline <- imputePeaksData(chr_eic, method = "spline")
chr_gaussian <- imputePeaksData(chr_eic, method = "gaussian",
                                window = 5, sd = 2)
chr_loess <- imputePeaksData(chr_eic, method = "loess", span = 0.3)

## Plot all methods for comparison
par(mfrow = c(3, 2), mar = c(4, 4, 2, 1))

## Original data
plotChromatograms(chr_eic, main = "Original EIC")

## Linear interpolation
plotChromatograms(chr_linear, main = "Linear Imputation")

## Spline interpolation
plotChromatograms(chr_spline, main = "Spline Imputation")

## Gaussian smoothing
plotChromatograms(chr_gaussian, main = "Gaussian Smoothing (window=5, sd=2)")

## LOESS smoothing
plotChromatograms(chr_loess, main = "LOESS Smoothing (span=0.3)")
```

## Selecting the right imputation method

The choice of imputation method depends on your data characteristics and
analysis goals:

- Use **"linear"** for quick interpolation of small gaps in regularly sampled
  data.
- Use **"spline"** for smooth curves when data is fairly regular, but be aware
  it can overshoot.
- Use **"gaussian"** for local smoothing that preserves peak shapes while
  filling gaps.
- Use **"loess"** when you want robust smoothing that adapts to local data
  density.

## Imputation in lazy evaluation pipelines

For on-disk backends like `ChromBackendMzR`, imputation is particularly useful
when combined with the lazy evaluation queue. The imputation function is added
to the processing queue and is only applied when peak data is actually accessed:

```{r}
## For on-disk backends, add imputation to the lazy queue
chr_mzr_imputed <- imputePeaksData(
  chr_mzr,
  method = "gaussian",
  window = 5,
  sd = 2
)

chr_mzr_imputed
```

The imputation is **not** performed immediately. Instead, it's stored in the
processing queue. When you call `peaksData()` on the object, the raw data is
read from the file and then imputation is applied on-the-fly:

```{r}
## This reads from disk and applies imputation in one step
peak_data <- peaksData(chr_mzr_imputed[1])
```

This approach is highly efficient for large datasets because:

1. Data is only read from disk when needed
2. Imputation is applied on-the-fly during data access
3. No temporary files are created
4. Memory usage remains minimal

You can verify the processing queue contains your imputation step:

```{r}
length(chr_mzr_imputed@processingQueue)
```

And if you want to make the imputation permanent (for in-memory backends),
use `applyProcessing()`:

```{r}
## For in-memory backends, you can persist the imputation
chr_in_memory <- setBackend(chr_mzr_imputed, ChromBackendMemory())
chr_in_memory <- applyProcessing(chr_in_memory)

# Now imputation is permanently applied
length(chr_in_memory@processingQueue)
```

# Session information

```{r si}
sessionInfo()
```
